Intrauterine devices (IUDs) are among the most effective forms of long-term birth control. However, like all medical devices and treatments, IUDs come with potential drawbacks. While many people use IUDs without serious issues, others may experience side effects, risks, or complications that make this method less ideal for their bodies and lifestyles.
What Is an IUD?
An IUD is a small, T-shaped device that a healthcare provider inserts into the uterus to prevent pregnancy. There are two main types:
- Hormonal IUDs (such as Mirena, Kyleena, Liletta, and Skyla) release a hormone called levonorgestrel.
- Copper IUDs (such as Paragard) do not contain hormones but use copper to prevent pregnancy.
Both types are highly effective, but each can have its own set of disadvantages.
Physical Side Effects
Cramping and Discomfort After Insertion
One of the most commonly reported drawbacks of an IUD is the discomfort during and shortly after insertion. The procedure can cause:
- Moderate to severe cramping
- Dizziness
- Light-headedness
- Spotting or light bleeding
This pain typically lasts a few hours to a few days, but for some, it may linger longer.
Ongoing Cramping or Pelvic Pain
Some individuals experience ongoing pelvic pain or cramps even after the initial adjustment period. This may happen more frequently with the copper IUD. If the pain is persistent or severe, the IUD may need to be removed.
Menstrual Changes
Heavier Periods and Worse Cramps (Copper IUD)
The copper IUD is known to increase menstrual flow and intensify period cramps, especially during the first few months. For some women, these symptoms can be disruptive enough to warrant removal of the device.
Irregular Bleeding (Hormonal IUD)
Hormonal IUDs often cause spotting and irregular bleeding for the first 3–6 months. While periods may become lighter or even stop altogether over time, the initial adjustment phase can be frustrating and unpredictable.
Risk of Expulsion
What Is IUD Expulsion?
Expulsion means that the IUD is partially or completely pushed out of the uterus. This can happen:
- During menstruation
- Within the first few months after insertion
- Without any noticeable symptoms
Expulsion rates are relatively low (around 2–10%), but if it happens, the IUD may no longer be effective at preventing pregnancy.
Who Is at Higher Risk?
Some people are at a higher risk of expulsion, including those who:
- Have heavy menstrual bleeding
- Have never been pregnant
- Are under 20 years old
- Have uterine abnormalities
Risk of Perforation
What Is Uterine Perforation?
In rare cases, an IUD can pierce the uterine wall during insertion. This complication is called uterine perforation and can lead to:
- Pain
- Damage to nearby organs
- Surgical removal of the IUD
How Common Is It?
Perforation is rare, occurring in about 1 in 1,000 insertions. However, it’s still a significant risk that should be discussed with a healthcare provider.
Possibility of Infection
Risk of Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (PID)
There is a small risk of developing pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) within the first 20 days of IUD insertion. PID is an infection of the reproductive organs that can lead to:
- Chronic pelvic pain
- Infertility
- Ectopic pregnancy
How Can It Be Prevented?
The risk of PID is higher if there’s already a sexually transmitted infection (STI) present at the time of insertion. Testing for STIs before insertion helps lower the risk. Practicing safe sex also reduces the chance of future infections.
Not Suitable for Everyone
Health Conditions and Uterine Abnormalities
Certain health conditions may make an IUD inappropriate or risky. These include:
- Uterine fibroids that distort the shape of the uterus
- Active pelvic infections
- Unexplained vaginal bleeding
- Certain cancers of the reproductive organs
Limited Use in Adolescents or Nulliparous Women
Although many healthcare professionals now consider IUDs safe for young women and those who haven’t given birth, some still hesitate to recommend them due to:
- Higher expulsion rates
- Narrower cervix, which can make insertion more painful
Delayed Fertility Return (Hormonal IUD)
Hormonal Adjustment After Removal
While fertility generally returns quickly after IUD removal, some women may experience a delay in regular ovulation, especially after using a hormonal IUD. This can be frustrating for those trying to conceive shortly after removal.
No Protection Against STIs
IUDs provide no protection against sexually transmitted infections. Those at higher risk of contracting an STI may need to use additional barrier methods, such as condoms.
Rare but Serious Complications
Ectopic Pregnancy
Although the overall risk of pregnancy with an IUD is very low, if pregnancy does occur, it’s more likely to be ectopic (outside the uterus), which is a medical emergency.
Allergic Reactions and Sensitivity
Rarely, users may experience allergic reactions to components of the IUD, such as:
- Sensitivity to copper (in copper IUDs)
- Reactions to plastic or hormones
Psychological or Emotional Impact
Anxiety About Having a Foreign Object Inside the Body
Some individuals feel mentally uncomfortable or anxious about having a device inside their uterus. This can affect:
- Peace of mind
- Sexual enjoyment
- General well-being
Worry About Side Effects
The potential for irregular bleeding, cramping, or rare complications may cause ongoing concern or stress, especially in those who are already prone to health anxiety.
Inconvenience of Insertion and Removal
Requires a Clinical Procedure
IUDs cannot be inserted or removed at home. The process involves:
- A pelvic exam
- An insertion procedure
- Possible follow-up visits
Similarly, removal requires a trained healthcare provider, which may not be convenient or accessible for everyone.
Cost and Insurance Barriers
High Upfront Cost (Without Insurance)
While IUDs can be cost-effective over the long term, the upfront cost can be high, ranging from $500 to $1,300 if not covered by insurance.
Access and Availability
Not all healthcare providers are trained to insert IUDs, and not all clinics stock every brand or type. This can limit options or delay access for some people.
IUD Displacement or Movement
Change in Position Over Time
Although rare, IUDs can shift position over time, which may:
- Reduce effectiveness
- Cause pain or discomfort
- Lead to complications like embedment in the uterine wall
Regular checkups and self-checks of the IUD strings are essential to monitor proper placement.
Summary: Is an IUD Right for You?
| Disadvantage | Type of IUD Affected | Severity/Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Cramping after insertion | Both | Common, short-term |
| Heavier periods | Copper | Common |
| Irregular bleeding | Hormonal | Common in first 3–6 months |
| Expulsion | Both | Rare to occasional |
| Perforation | Both | Rare |
| PID/infection risk | Both | Rare with precautions |
| Not suitable for all | Both | Case-dependent |
| No STI protection | Both | Always true |
| Ectopic pregnancy risk | Both | Rare |
| Inconvenient insertion/removal | Both | Always required |
| High upfront cost | Both | Depends on coverage |
Final Thoughts
IUDs are a safe and effective form of long-term contraception for many people, but they are not without downsides. From physical side effects to rare but serious complications, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons carefully.
If you’re considering an IUD, consult your healthcare provider to discuss:
- Your health history
- Your lifestyle and comfort
- The type of IUD that might suit you best
No birth control method is perfect, and the key is finding the one that aligns with your body and your needs.
You Might Be Interested In:
- New Study Reveals Optimal Water Temperature for Pregnancy Baths
- Gestational Diabetes: Causes, Symptoms, Diagnosis & Treatment
- Telemedicine Expands Access to Contraception in Post-Roe America
